IS ISLAMIC BANKING PERFORMANCE IN MALAYSIA TRULY BETTER THAN INDONESIA?
Abstract
This article analyzes the performance of Islamic banking in Malaysia and Indonesia using a comprehensive evaluation framework. Malaysia is known for its leading role in Islamic finance, while Indonesia has faced criticism for slower growth. The study argues that assessing Islamic banking performance solely based on financial metrics is insufficient and proposes a broader framework based on the Maqasid Shariah (objectives of Islamic law) for a more objective standard. Using data from 2010 to 2019, the study constructs a Maqasid Shariah Index of Islamic Bank (MSI-iB) and adopts a T-test as well as a panel data model to evaluate their performance. The index includes five sub-indices representing different aspects of the Maqasid Shariah framework. Results show varied scores among Islamic banks in both countries with no statistical difference between the two countries, but with Indonesia leading in religiosity and intellectuality dimensions and Malaysia leading in the posterity dimension. These results challenge the perception that Malaysia's Islamic banking performance is inherently superior to Indonesia's based solely on financial metrics. Considering the Maqasid Shariah framework is crucial to evaluating Islamic banking performance, highlighting the significance of non-financial indicators. The study concludes that a comprehensive perspective is necessary, incorporating both financial and non-financial factors, to assess overall performance.
References
Abdelsalam, O., Dimitropoulos, P., Elnahass, M., & Leventis, S. (2016). Earnings management behaviors under different monitoring mechanisms: The case of Islamic and conventional banks. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 132(Supplement), 155-173.
Abedifar, P., Ebrahim, S., Molyneux, P., & Tarazi, A. (2015). Islamic banking and finance: Recent empirical literature and directions for future research. Journal of Economic Surveys, 29(4), 637-670.
Akhtar, M. F., Ali, K., & Sadaqat, S. (2011). Factors influencing the profitability of Islamic banks of Pakistan. International Research Journal of Finance and Economics, 66(66), 125-132.
Alhammadi, S., Alotaibi, K. O., & Hakam, D. F. (2022). Analysing Islamic banking ethical performance from Maqāṣid al-Sharī‘ah perspective: Evidence from Indonesia. Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment, 12(4), 1171-1193.
Al-Malkawi, H. A. N., & Pillai, R. (2018). Analyzing financial performance by integrating conventional governance mechanisms into the GCC Islamic banking framework. Managerial Finance, 44(5), 604-623.
Al-Qaradawi, Y. (1999). A comparative study. London: Dar al-Taqwa Ltd.
Amin, H. (2022). Maqasid-based consumer preference index for Islamic home financing. International Journal of Ethics and Systems, 38(1), 47-67.
Anbar, A., & Alper, D. (2011). Bank specific and macroeconomic determinants of commercial bank profitability: Empirical evidence from Turkey. Business and Economics Research Journal, 2(2), 139-152.
Antonio, M. S., Sanrego, Y. D., & Taufiq, M. (2012). An analysis of Islamic banking performance: Maqashid index implementation in Indonesia and Jordania. Journal of Islamic Finance, 1(1), 12-29.
Ascarya, A., & Indra. (2022). Standard Methodology for Research in Islamic Economics and Finance (Chapter 17). In Billah, M.M. (Ed). Teaching and Research Methods in Islamic Economics and Finance. Abingdon-on-Thames, England, UK: Routledge.
Ascarya, A., & Masrifah, A. R. (2023). Developing maqasid index for Islamic CSR: The case of Ummah’s endowment fund in Indonesia. International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 16(4), 835-855.
Ascarya, A., & Yumanita, D. (2008). Comparing the efficiency of Islamic banks in Malaysia and Indonesia. Buletin Ekonomi Moneter dan Perbankan, 11(2), 95-119.
Ascarya, Sukmana, R., & Rahmawati, S. (2015). Formulating Islamic bank maqashid index. Paper presented at “Roundtable Policy Discussion on Maqashid Shariah”, organized by IRCIEF-KUIS and IRTI-IDB, Kajang, Malaysia, April 27-29, 2015.
Ascarya, Rahmawati, S., & Sukmana, R. (2016). Measuring the Islamicity of Islamic bank in Indonesia and other countries based on Shari’ah objectives. Paper presented at the 11th Islamic Conference on Islamic Economics and Finance, organized by International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM), Islamic Research and Training Institute – Islamic Development Bank (IRTI-IDB) and International Association of Islamic Economics (IAIE), Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, October 11-13, 2016.
Asutay, M., & Harningtyas, A. F. (2015). Developing maqasid al-Shari’ah index to evaluate social performance of Islamic banks: A conceptual and empirical attempt. International Journal of Islamic Economics and Finance Studies, 1(1), 5-64.
Auda, J. (2022). Maqasid al-Shari'ah as philosophy of Islamic law. International Herndon, USA: Institute of Islamic Thought (IIIT).
Aysan, A. F., Disli, M., & Ozturk, H. (2018). Bank lending channel in a dual banking system: Why are Islamic banks so responsive? The World Economy, 41(3), 674-698.
Beck, T., Demirgüç-Kunt, A., & Merrouche, O. (2013). Islamic vs. conventional banking: Business model, efficiency and stability. Journal of Banking & Finance, 37(2), 433-447.
Bedoui, H. E. (2012). Ethical competitive advantage for Islamic finance institutions: How should they measure their performance? Paper presented at the 9th Harvard University Forum on Islamic Finance, Harvard Law School, March 24-25, 2012: 1-22.
Bedoui, H. E., & Mansour, W. (2014). Performance and maqasid al-shari’ah’s pentagon-shaped ethical measurement. Science and Engineering Ethics, 21(3), 555–576.
Belal, A., Abdelsalam, O., & Nizamee, S. (2014). Ethical reporting in Islami bank Bangladesh limited (1983-2010). Journal of Business Ethics, 129(4), 769–784.
Bitar, M., Saad, W., & Benlemlih, M. (2016). Bank risk and performance in the MENA region: The importance of capital requirements. Economic Systems, 40(3), 398-421.
Chapra, M. U. (2008). The Islamic vision of development in the light of maqasid al-shariah. Jeddah: Islamic Research and Training Institute Islamic Development Bank.
Fahlevi, H., Irsyadillah & Randa, P. (2017). Financial performance and sharia compliance: A comparative analysis of Indonesian and Malaysian Islamic banks. DLSU Business and Economics Review, 26(2), 41-52.
Farook, S. M., Hassan, K., & Lanis, R. (2011). Determinants of corporate social responsibility disclosure: The case of Islamic banks. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 2(2), 114–141.
Goddard, J., Molyneux, P., & Wilson, J. O. (2004). The profitability of European banks: A cross-sectional and dynamic panel analysis. Manchester School, 72(3), 363-381.
Haniffa, R. & Hudaib, M. (2007). Exploring the ethical identity of Islamic banks via communication in annual reports. Journal of Business Ethics, 76, 97-116.
Islamic Financial Services Board (IFSB). (2022). Islamic Financial Services Industry Stability Report, p. 16.
Jatmiko, W., & Azizon, A. (2022). Can religious values reinvigorate the links between development and falāh?. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 13(1), 32-53.
Kabir, M. R., Sobhani, F. A., Omar, N., & Mohamad, N. (2019). Corporate governance and risk disclosures: A comparative analysis between Bangladeshi and Malaysian Islamic banks. International Journal of Financial Research, 11(5), 110-125.
Karim, R. A. A., & Archer, S. (2013). Islamic finance: The new regulatory challenge. Singapore: John Wiley & Sons.
Kasri, R., & Kassim, S. H. (2009). Empirical determinants of saving in the Islamic banks: Evidence from Indonesia. Journal of King Abdulaziz University: Islamic Economics, 22(2), 181-201.
Maghfuriyah, A., Azama, S. M. F., & Shukri, S. (2019). Market structure and Islamic banking performance in Indonesia: An error correction model. Management Science Letters, 9, 1407–1418.
Malim, N. A. K., Masron, T. A., & Pitchay, A. A. (2017). Determinants of Islamic banks’ margins in Asian countries. Journal of Islamic Finance, 6, 46-53.
Masyita, D. (2017). Islamic microfinance institutions in Indonesia and the challenges in the supply chain perspectives. International Journal of Supply Chain Management, 6(4), 341-351.
Masyita, D., & Ahmed, H. (2013). Why is growth of Islamic microfinance lower than its conventional counterpart in Indonesia?. Islamic Economics Studies (IES) Journal, 21(1), 35-62.
Mergaliyev, A., Asutay, M., Avdukic, A., & Karbhari, Y. (2021). Higher ethical objective (Maqasid al-Shari’ah) augmented framework for Islamic banks: Assessing ethical performance and exploring its determinants. Journal of Business Ethics, 170, 797-834.
Mohammed, M. O., Razak, D. A., & Taib, F. M. (2008). The performance measures of Islamic banking based on the Maqasid framework. The IIUM International Accounting Conference (INTAC IV), Putrajaya Marroitt, Malaysia, June 25, 2008.
Mohammed, M. O., & Taib, F. M. (2015). Developing Islamic banking performance measures based on maqasid al-shari’ah framework: Case of 24 selected banks. Journal of Islamic Monetary Economics and Finance, 1(1), 55-78.
Rahman, R. A., Alsmady, A., Ibrahim, Z., & Muhammad, A. D. (2014). Risk management practices in Islamic banking institutions: A comparative study between Malaysia and Jordan. Journal of Applied Business Research, 30(5), 1295-1304.
Rashid, A., & Jabeen, S. (2016). Analyzing performance determinants: Conventional versus Islamic banks in Pakistan. Borsa Istanbul Review, 16(2), 92-107.
Rizkiningsih, P., & Dewi, M. K. (2015). Factors influencing Islamic social reporting (ISR): An empirical study in Islamic banks in Indonesia, Malaysia and the GCC countries. In M. Asutay & A. Q. Turkistani (Eds.), Islamic finance: Performance and efficiency. Berlin: Gerlach Press. pp. 287–308.
Siddiqi, M. N. (2006). Islamic banking and finance in theory and practice: A survey of state of the art. Islamic Economic Studies, 13(2), 1-48.
Srairi, S. (2019). Transparency and bank risk-taking in GCC Islamic banking. Borsa Istanbul Review, 19(1), 64-74.
Tajgardoon, G., Behname, M., & Noormohamadi, K. (2012). Is profitability as a result of market power or efficiency in Islamic banking industry? Economics and Finance Review, 2(5), 01-07.
The Islamic Corporation for the Development of the Private Sector (ICD)-Refinitiv (2022). Islamic Finance Development Report 2022: Embracing Change, p. 30.
Zouari, S. B. S., & Taktak, N. B. (2012). Ownership structure and financial performance in Islamic banks: Does bank ownership matter? Working Paper No. 713. The Economic Research Forum (ERF).
Zulkhibri, M. (2018). The impact of monetary policy on Islamic bank financing: Bank-level evidence from Malaysia. Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Science, 23(46), 306-322.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Journal of Islamic Monetary Economics and Finance is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
